No, actually he makes a fair point. It's already been said that post should be constructive, not just an obvious attempt at making fun of it. It's just like the situation we had a little while ago about offtopicness, I can't remember what mod said (I beleive it was Zeph) who pointed out the posts where people are just ranting on, and in an attempt to make it look like they're not being offtopic they put in some lame comment at the end to pretend like they really care about being on topic. Same sort of deal here, people really intending to make fun of it, and tacking on a half-assed peice of constructive critism to make it look like they're obeying the rules. C'mon guys, it's obvious the problem was with disaster and not this guy anyhow.