Quote Originally Posted by SnaFuBAR View Post
You have got to be joking. That model barely looks like a Thompson. As for your wood, it's ok, but still not at all like what's on a Thompson, and as for your metal, way too cloudy/spongey/soft with random nonsense scratches all over it. Terrible, redo it.
eh I thought the metal looked good but now that u mention it, it does have some nonsense scratches, I don't think it calls for re-doing it. It really depends what hes trying to achieve though.


It looks realistic enough for a game to me... then again thats why I say whats he trying to achieve. If its meant to be for realisim then yes it has problems, imo it looks to perfect to be real. (talking texture wise, the model looks good to me, but I don't know much if anything about guns)

The wood has almost no imperfections in it, thats the main problem I see in it right now, keep working on it. I really don't think you need to redo it unless your really going for complete realism like snaf up there is.

E: reminds me of the thompson from MOHAA (metal of honor allied assualt)