Quote Originally Posted by m13120 View Post
Tbh I don't care much for all these Halo 3 weapons being remade in CE, especially the Halo 3 version of the pistol. I could give less a shit about how it looks or such things. I wouldn't play a map with a Halo 3 Pistol in it because like I said, I could care less how it looks, since it will look similar to the Halo 1 version, and it will play the same exact way as the regular Halo 1 Pistol is used in gameplay, or it could just make the gameplay worse. There is almost no possibility that the gameplay will be better.

Oh yeah? And an overpowered godpistol makes better gameplay? No, this pistol is far more balanced, however in CE with no duel wielding ability it will be useless. Now, if someone gave it a higher rate of fire than the halo 3 magnum, then yes I think it would be useful. 5 headshots with the same ROF as the halo 1 pistol would satisfy me, however the clip would also need to be larger. And are you overall implying that halo 1 has better gameplay than halo 3? If so, I disagree. Halo 3 has a poor melee system, but the weapons are more balanced than in halo 1, where the only weapons of use are the shotgun, pistol and sniper. In halo 3, it is plausible to get a kill with any weapon, and there isn't really a sense of "OMG I CANT BELIEVE I GOT KILLED BY (insert weapon here)!" because they're all fairly capable.