Because, there are people who played the first one more just because it was a fast paced cluster fuck of 64 players, and they loved that. Then there were the people who just enjoyed the game play regardless of how many people were actually in a server. You can't say a game sucks because of their reckless decision to bone PC players. I got it for console because I enjoy the style of game play it brings and I feel they fixed a lot of balance issues with the first one. Overall I'm impressed with their work and I find it quite enjoyable. I'm not a fanboy, I couldn't give two shits. I just happen to like what they gave me. And other people, especially reviewers, who can over look the shitty end of the stick PC players got and look into the actual game play will probably say the same thing.