Most reviews on Newegg are bullshit anyways. The 5/5 and 4/5 ones are usually legit, though. My friend uses one of the discontinued H50 coolers and doesn't have an issue with it. He's had it for about a year and a half now, too. If I hadn't seen it in operation myself I wouldn't have even considered looking into a liquid cooled solution. Custom liquid cooling is the best for cooling, but it's too damn expensive and too much work to maintain, and then you have to worry about leakages.