Quote Originally Posted by Atty View Post
You haven't played it and yet you are passing judgement.
These people are judging what they can. They're expressing initial thoughts based on what they've seen. They're allowed to do that, and it's no worse than blindly defending it, or having no thought on the matter whatsoever. It's topical discussion, and I don't see what's wrong with it. Some people may be mistaking the thought of "this looks terrible" with "this is terrible" . I don't think anyone is seriously suggesting that they have definitively made up their mind on the quality of a game that isn't even out in public beta yet. That's just silly.